The 4th Annual International Symposium on University Rankings and Quality Assurance 2012:
Rankings as a Global Tool – National, Regional and International Perspectives
Key Speakers
|
Mr. Jordi Curell, Director, Lifelong Learning: Higher Education and International Affairs, DG EAC, European Commission |
|
Mr. Gero Federkeil, Head of Rankings, CHE – Centre for Educational Development; Vice President, The Observatory on Academic Ranking and Excellence |
|
Mr. Phil Baty, Deputy Editor, Times Higher Education, and Editor of Times Higher Education World University Rankings, UK |
|
Mr. Waldemar Siwiński, Vice President, IREG Observatory on Academic Ranking and Excellence; President, Polish Education Foundation “Perspektywy” |
|
Prof. Andrea Bonaccorsi, University of Pisa and the Board of the National Agency for the Evaluation of Universities and Research Institutes (ANVUR) |
|
Prof. Andrés Carrión García, Director, Centre For Quality And Change Management, Valencia University Of Technology |
|
Prof. Martí Parellada, General Coordinator of the CYD Report; Head of the Ranking Project of the CYD Foundation, Spain |
|
Dr. Karsten Krueger, Project Manager of the Ranking Project of the CYD Foundation, Spain |
The concept of university rankings is rapidly becoming one of the most important tools used by both students and academic professionals across the world. Currently, there are 33 countries which possess some form of rankings system, and the field continues to grow both domestically and internationally. Universities use them to define their performance, professional reputation and status, whilst students use them to choose their future place of study and research. What originated as a consumer product aimed at undergraduate domestic students has now become both a manifestation and a driver of global competition and a battle for excellence in itself.
As the higher education sector is recognised as one of the key drivers of economic growth, the productivity, quality and the status of research produced by institutions can be used as a vital indicator. Recognising the need for greater clarity, the European Commission has launched its own initiatives (U-Multirank and U-Map) that are independent from public authorities and universities. Its aim is the design and testing of a new multidimensional university ranking system, one with a more global outreach. It is hoped that a comprehensive ranking system will assist policymakers in developing longer term strategies as part of the broader Higher Education modernisation agenda.
This annual international symposium, now in its fourth year, will assess the challenges that lie ahead in creating and maintaining comprehensive and user-friendly systems for ranking universities. Indicators and data collection are key areas which need to be addressed and explored through an integrated and joined-up approach under the guidance of the European Commission. The symposium offers an invaluable opportunity to discuss the dynamics between international rankings and national initiatives developed in various countries, collaborate and communicate strategies and share best practices.
Public Policy Exchange welcomes the participation of all key partners, responsible authorities and stakeholders. The symposium will support the exchange of ideas and encourage delegates to engage in thought-provoking topical debate.
Delegates will:
- Analyse and discuss the mechanisms for defining performance, professional reputation and status of universities through user-friendly rankings
- Consider how to facilitate student and staff participation and access to information
- Explore challenges to existing systems in rankings, data collection and indicators
- Share best practices from the implementation of the rankings system nationally and internationally
Programme
| 09:00 |
Registration and Morning Refreshments
|
| 10:00 |
Chair’s Welcome and Opening Remarks
Prof. Andrea Bonaccorsi, University of Pisa and the Board of the National Agency for the Evaluation of Universities and Research Institutes (ANVUR) (confirmed)
|
| 10:10 |
Standards for International Rankings – Current and Future Developments
- The Future Development of U-Multirank
- CHE Approach for Cooperation of National Field-Based Rankings
- Efficiency of Rankings – Coordination between Data Collection Activities for National and International Rankings
- Standards Set by the New IREG-Audit for Rankings
- Recommendations
Speakers:
Mr. Jordi Curell, Director, Lifelong Learning: Higher Education and International Affairs, DG EAC, European Commission (confirmed)
Mr. Gero Federkeil, Manager in Charge of Rankings, CHE-Centre for Educational Development and Vice President of the Observatory on Academic Ranking and Excellence (confirmed)
|
| 10:50 |
First Round of Discussions |
| 11:30 |
Morning Coffee Break
|
| 11:50 |
Session Two: University Rankings - Facilitating Students’ Participation and Access to Services and Information
- New Standard in International University Performance Comparisons – Lessons Learned
- Linking National with Regional and International Rankings
- Using Data in a Integrated Way – Challenges and Opportunities
- Promoting Rankings Nationally and Internationally
- Recommendations
Speakers:
Mr. Phil Baty, Deputy Editor, Times Higher Education, and Editor of Times Higher Education World University Rankings, UK (confirmed)
Mr. Waldemar Siwiński, Vice President of the IREG Observatory on Academic Ranking and Excellence and President of the Polish Education Foundation “Perspektywy” (confirmed)
|
| 12:40 |
Second Round of Discussions |
| 13:10 |
Networking Lunch |
| 14:10 |
Session Three: Creating Effective European Data System and Indicators on University Rankings
- Possible Relationship with Other International Data
- Promoting Development and Harmonization of Existing Data Institutions
- Improving Data on Employment-Oriented Outcome Indicators
- Field Specific Data and Institutional Level Data
- Regional Engagement and Knowledge Transfer
- Measuring University Third Mission
- Recommendations
Speakers:
Prof. Andrea Bonaccorsi, University of Pisa and the Board of the National Agency for the Evaluation of Universities and Research Institutes (ANVUR) (confirmed)
Prof. Andrés Carrión García Director, the Centre for Quality and Change Management, Valencia University of Technology (confirmed)
|
| 15:00 |
Third Round of Discussions |
| 15:30 |
Short Coffee Break |
| 15:45 |
Case Study Panel Session Four:
Implementing a Field-Based Ranking System in Europe
- Best Practices and Lessons Learned
- Bottom-Up and Top-Down Ranking Approaches
- Developing Trust and Credibility
- Recommendations
Speaker:
Prof. Martí Parellada, General Coordinator of the CYD Report; Head of the Ranking Project of the CYD Foundation, Spain (confirmed)
Dr. Karsten Krueger, Project Manager of the Ranking Project of the CYD Foundation, Spain (confirmed)
|
| 16:15 |
Fourth Round of Discussion |
| 16:45 |
Chair’s Summary and Closing Remarks |
| 16:55 |
Networking Reception and Refreshments |
| 17:25 |
Symposium Close |
Who Should Attend?
- Registrars and Senior University Administrators
- Faculty Deans
- University Chancellors and Vice-Chancellors
- Rankings Agencies
- Quality Assurance Institutes
- Researchers
- Academics
- National Ministries for Education
- International Organisations
- Higher Education Organisations
- Employer’s Organisations
- Data Centres
- Standardisation Organisations
- Careers Services and Advisers
- Admissions Bodies
- Research Councils
- Schools and FE Colleges
- Funding Bodies
- Local Authority Education Officers
- Representatives of Industry and Commerce
- Education Charities and NGOs
- Lifelong Learning Practitioners
- Equal Opportunities Officers
- Access Officers
- Disability Practitioners
- Campaigning Organisations
News
17
PM: UK my priority in euro crisis
David Cameron has said it is his job to keep the UK safe whatever the fate of the eurozone.
More17
McDonnell tops MPs' bill ballot
Labour MP John McDonnell has come first in the ballot for Private Member's Bills, which allow MPs to introduce legislation on a subject of their choice.
More17
Councils 'must lower emissions'
Local authorities across the UK should have a statutory duty to combat climate change, government advisors recommend.
More
“As part of Europe's strategy for jobs and growth, the European
Commission today presented a reform strategy to boost graduate
numbers, improve teaching quality and maximise what higher
education can do to help the EU economy emerge stronger from the
crisis. The strategy identifies priority areas where EU countries need
to do more to achieve shared education objectives and sets out how
the European Union can support their modernisation policies. EUlevel
initiatives will include university ranking which will better inform
students about the courses which are best for them and an 'Erasmus
for Masters' loan guarantee scheme for students taking a full degree
course abroad.”
European Commission Press Release, 11 September 2011
“IREG Observatory plans to undertake a responsibility in raising the quality and
standards of university rankings [for institutional and program rankings] exactly
taking into consideration the increasing importance of rankings among future
students, and the fact that rankings can influence financial decisions of government
bodies responsible for higher education. Concretely, IREG Observatory is finalizing
a methodology and procedures for audit system of university rankings. The “IREG
audit” will be carried out upon those producing rankings and assess their rankings
against the highest methodology standards. Those rankings that will pass the
IREG audit will be entitled to use “IREG Recognized” label. Such audits will become
an important force to give both the public and academia confidence that higher
education rankings are being conducted using high standards. The audit criteria of
university rankings will be based foremost on the Berlin Principles on Ranking of
Higher Education Institutions which were established by IREG in Berlin in 2006”
Dr. Jan Sadlak, President of IREG Observatory, 12 April 2010